hreflang="en-us"

Metal Fabrication: What’s Inside a Typical Metal Part

It’s a pretty common object, a steel bracket. Perhaps it has four holes, two bends, a protective coating. And once it is in place, nobody is likely to think about it much.

But suppose you were asked to make 600 of them.

The first issue is not to cut the steel. It’s about figuring out how to make the same bracket 600 times without spending half the day fiddling with equipment, fixing bends or trying to get holes to align.

Now reverse the order to six brackets. Or switch the material to stainless steel. Or install a welded reinforcement in an inaccessible place.

The drawing may not change much. The manufacturing job, it sure does.

This is often missing from general descriptions of metal fabrication. Cutting, bending and welding are simple enough to explain. It takes experience to know what combination will work, how much preparation it deserves and whether another manufacturing method would make the job easier.

A Fabrication Shop Is Not About the Finished Shape

Most of the manufactured metal products start life as something fairly ordinary. Sheet, plate, tube, bar or a length of structural steel.

They are useful in that they can be bought in standard forms and fabricated into a wide variety of products. That way, a fabricator doesn’t have to create a new piece of raw material each time someone calls in for a different bracket or enclosure.

The work is about changing what is already there.

Sheet metal can be cut and bent to make cabinets, guards and equipment covers. Steel sections may be cut and joined to form frames. The tubes are suitable for use as railings or in larger assemblies.

In shop language, metal fabrication usually means cutting, forming and joining these materials into useful parts or structures. Processes include laser cutting, punching, bending, welding and mechanical fastening.

Not every job needs all of them.

After cutting and forming, a bent aluminum panel may be finished. In a structural frame there may be little forming, but there is much fitting and welding.

Casting and forging are often considered as part of fabrication, although they take a different approach to the problem. Instead of building a shape from standard stock, they can make a part much closer to the final form.

That difference matters when the shape begins to battle the manufacturing method.

The Trouble With Making Everything Out of Flat Steel

A flat sheet is a good starting point until the design ceases to be particularly flat.

Picture a small cabinet of equipment. A fabricator can cut the panels, shape the edges and piece together into a box. You can make cutouts for cables, switches and ventilation.

This is a reasonable way to go for a fairly simple enclosure.

Now imagine the designer adds a bunch of internal compartments, curved surfaces and awkward mounting features. The shop might require more separate parts, more bends and a complicated assembly process.

The enclosure is still technically feasible to build. This doesn’t make the design easy to manufacture.

Each additional piece has to be placed. Each joint adds another operation. Depending on the design, welding may cause distortion that must be controlled or corrected.

And there is also a practical matter of access. A weld that seems perfectly acceptable on a drawing may be hard to access once the surrounding panels are in place.

Experienced fabricators can spot these problems quickly having seen what happens when a clean drawing meets a real workbench.

Sometimes a small design change makes the job a lot easier. You can move a joint, alter a bend or permit another fastening and get rid of work without changing the purpose of the end product.

A Bend Is Not What You Asked For

Bending sheet metal sounds simple enough. Then the material goes in a press brake and with force applied the sheet gets new shape.

The problem is, naturally, that metal does not behave like a lump of soft clay.

The material recovers part of its elastic deformation when bent. This is called springback, which means that the angle of the finished piece may not be the same as the angle imposed during forming.

The quantity depends on the material, its thickness and the forming conditions.

A fabricator might be able to make changes with one bracket during setup. In a production run, those adjustments have to produce consistent results.

A small mistake can be surprisingly bad. When two bent panels are to be joined along a narrow edge, a small difference in angle can result in a visible gap or make fastening of the assembly difficult.

This problem is more apparent when multiple bends contribute to the final dimensions.

Material specs play a role here. Two sheets that look identical may not behave quite the same if they differ in alloy or condition.

This is part of the reason why a shop needs more than a drawing and a request to make the part as cheaply as possible.

When Casting Saves More Work Than It Creates

There is a certain shape for which joining and cutting separate pieces is a bad way of making it.

A good example is a housing for a pump. It may need curved internal passageways, substantial wall sections and mounting features placed around a complex body.

That’d be a lot of assembly work trying to make that whole shape out of cut pieces.

Casting is a different place to start. Molten metal fills a mold and solidifies into a shape that may have features difficult to make by conventional fabrication.

The attraction is obvious, much of the geometry can be created in one go.

But the work has not gone away. Some of it has gone elsewhere.

The mold has to be designed. The metal should solidify in a controlled manner. Shrinkage, porosity and other defects may need to be controlled during casting. Depending on the casting method, patterns, cores and other tools may be needed.

The finished casting may also require machining. The locations of bearings, sealing faces and mounting surfaces often require more precise dimensions or finishes than can be obtained from the casting process alone.

This can still be an efficient path to manufacture for a product made in significant quantities.

But in one experimental housing the preparation may be hard to justify. The fabricated or machined alternative may be more practical even if it’s more operations on an individual basis.

Casting is not the easy version of fabrication. It covers a different set of problems.

Changes Forge Both Shape and Metal

Forging will often be presented as a way to make stronger parts. That’s an incomplete explanation, and it can lead to some bad comparisons.

The basic process involves applying force to deform solid metal. Depending on the alloy and the method being used, the material may be heated.

In casting, the metal is melted and poured into a mold, but this is not the case in other processes.

The deformation process can affect the inner structure and the mechanical properties of the material. This makes forging useful for some components that have to withstand demanding service conditions.

Imagine a highly stressed mechanical part, not just a simple equipment cover.

The manufacturer may be interested in fatigue performance, toughness or material behavior under repeated loading. A suitable forging process can help meet particular mechanical requirements.

But forging doesn’t guarantee better performance.

A poorly designed or improperly processed forging can have its own problems. Alloy choice, heat treatment, component geometry and quality control all make a difference.

To make the required shape, forging also needs the right equipment and tooling. The part might still require some machining or finishing.

For a lightly loaded bracket these additional requirements may provide little useful benefit. Cutting and forming stock material may be more than sufficient.

The question is not whether forging is better than fabrication. It is whether the properties and production possibilities of forging make it worthwhile for that part.

The Non-Substitution Substitution

Sometimes material changes are treated as if they were buying decisions.

A customer orders mild steel and later switches to stainless steel because the end product will be exposed to moisture. The dimensions do not change, so the customer expects the manufacturing process to be the same as well.

It might not.

The new material can behave differently in terms of forming and joining. Surface requirements are subject to change. The fabricator may have to rethink tooling, preparation or the assembly technique.

Aluminum alloys are no different. Two grades may look alike, but have very different forming characteristics.

There are good reasons to go for a more demanding material. Corrosion resistance, weight, strength and operating temperature may all be important to the finished component.

But there are manufacturing implications to these benefits.

There are some applications where a different alloy might mean a lighter component or less need for a protective coating. In some cases it creates additional work in production without any meaningful improvement.

The decision also ripples beyond the workshop. Material availability, certification requirements and supply reliability can affect what can be manufactured.

This is especially the case for specialty alloys that rely on critical minerals or highly controlled supply chains.

The drawing indicates the material from which the finished part shall be made. It doesn’t necessarily tell you what that choice will mean on the plant floor.

Six Parts and Six Thousand Parts Are Different Tasks

In a shop, surprisingly, a lot of time is spent getting ready to make something.

There may be cutting programs to make, fixtures to set up, material to prepare, and a sequence of operations to figure out.

For six custom brackets, it may not make much sense to do a lot of preparation. An experienced fabricator could make them with general purpose equipment and simple setups .

For 6,000 brackets the math changes.

When repeated thousands of times, even a small amount of unnecessary handling becomes significant. If a fixture costs a little more but saves a little time on each part, then over a long production run it can be justified.

The order in which you do things matters, too.

Where cutting, bending and welding are necessary to manufacture a component, the manufacturer must consider the sequence of these processes and how the part will be held during production.

A great prototype may come from a process that is hard for the shop to reproduce consistently.

The opposite can occur, too. Once established, a specialized production system can be very efficient but uneconomical for a short run.

This is where the conversation around automation can get tricky.

In the right production environment, a robotic welding system or automated cutting line may be worth the investment. That doesn’t mean every fabrication job requires the same investment.

A shop doing custom one-off repairs and assemblies has different needs than a manufacturer producing thousands of identical enclosures.

The amount of work is not just a factor in the cost per part. It can change what manufacturing process makes sense initially.

RMB’s Take: Measure the Work Done After the Shape Has Been Made

One way to compare fabrication, casting and forging is not to declare a winner among them.

After the main shaping operation, look at what’s left to do.

While a fabricated enclosure may be inexpensive to cut and bend, it could still require considerable fitting, welding, finishing and inspection.

Most of the complex geometry may already be present in a casting, but machining, defect inspection and surface treatment may still be required.

A forged part may have suitable material properties and a near-final shape, but require trimming, heat treatment or precision finishing.

At RareMetalBlog, we consider this remaining work one of the most useful things to examine when comparing manufacturing routes.

The operation that gives a component its recognizable shape is usually the easiest part to describe. The less obvious costs often hover around it.

How many times does the part need handling? Does it need repositioning? Are separate pieces being connected? How much inspection is required? And what happens when an operation produces a defect?

Even when the component seems simple, these questions are important.

The RMB Remaining-Work Assessment

Manufacturing route Work that may remain What RMB would examine
Cut, bent and assembled fabrication Fitting, joining, distortion correction, surface finishing and inspection Whether separate parts and repeated handling create unnecessary work
Casting Removal of casting-related material, machining, defect inspection and finishing Whether the geometry produced by the mold offsets tooling and secondary-operation requirements
Forging Trimming, heat treatment, machining, finishing and inspection Whether the required mechanical properties justify the additional processing

These aren’t fixed production steps. A simple fabricated component might require no welding at all. Some castings and forgings need very little finishing, while others require extensive secondary work.

The point is to identify the work that the initial manufacturing choice leaves behind.

Suppose you need a metal housing for a new industrial product.

During development, it may be convenient to build it from laser-cut and welded sections. The design can change without needing an entirely new casting tool.

If the product makes it into mass production, casting might deserve another look. It could remove some joints and assembly operations.

That doesn’t necessarily mean it’s cheaper. Casting tooling, inspection and finishing must still be considered.

The argument works in reverse, too. A part that looks like an obvious casting candidate may be easier to fabricate if only a handful are required.

This is RMB’s editorial assessment based on established manufacturing principles, not a statement that we’ve tested these hypothetical parts or received production quotes.

The Cheapest-Looking Process Can Turn Out to Be the Expensive One

Let’s say a manufacturer has a pair of proposals for the same metal assembly.

One uses a number of cut pieces welded together. The other starts with a casting and machines a couple critical surfaces.

The first proposal has no dedicated casting tooling, which sounds attractive.

But maybe the welded assembly needs a lot of fitting and correcting. Or maybe the casting requires more inspection and finishing than was anticipated.

And the first comparison tells you nothing at all unless you consider the whole route of production.

There’s another wrinkle: designs don’t always remain fixed.

If the manufacturer expects frequent changes, fabricated parts may offer useful flexibility. A business that has been making the same component for years might be more willing to invest in specialized tooling.

Neither is more developed as a matter of course.

A sensible way of producing is one that satisfies the needs of the component without creating unnecessary work elsewhere.

Metal Fabrication Rarely Operates in Isolation

Look closely at a piece of industrial equipment and you can often find multiple manufacturing methods in the same assembly.

The supporting frame may be made of steel sections welded together. A housing may be cast. A shaft may begin as a forging or a bar. Covers and guards may be made from sheet metal, while critical surfaces may require metal machining.

You can use them all and there is no contradiction.

Every manufacturing process has its strengths. The final product doesn’t care if its parts came from a casting mold, a press brake or a welding bench. It has to work well.

The trick is to assemble those pieces in a consistent way, in the right volume, at a price the project can pay for.

That’s the part of metal fabrication worth listening to. Not just what a machine can do, but if it is the right machine, using the right material, at the right point in the manufacturing process.

Metal Fabrication FAQs

Manufacturing and Metal Fabrication: What’s the Difference?

Manufacturing is the general term for the process of making products from raw materials and components. Metal fabrication is a term that is commonly used to mean the cutting, forming, joining and assembly of metal parts. In some technical settings, fabrication is used more broadly to encompass other metalworking processes.

Is Casting Part of Metal Fabrication?

It is contingent upon your use of the word. Casting does fall under some generalizations of metal fabrication but in day to day workshop lingo casting and traditional fabrication are often separate processes. Casting is the forming of metal by solidification in a mold; fabrication is generally working with existing solid stock.

What Is the Difference Between Casting and Forging?

Casting is the process of pouring molten metal into a mold and allowing it to solidify. Forging is when you press or hit solid metal so that it changes shape, sometimes when it is very hot. The choice of these depends on the geometry of the component, the material requirements and the production conditions.

What Are the Most Common Metals Used in Fabrication?

Carbon steel , stainless steel and aluminum alloys are widely used . Copper alloys and specialty metals are also selected for certain applications. The choice is dictated by the properties required in the finished part and by the behavior of the material during fabrication.

Does Metal Fabrication Always Require Welding?

No. Some of the fabricated parts are completely cut and bent. Others are joined using bolts, rivets or other mechanical fastener methods. Welding is common , but the proper method of joining depends on the design and the application of the completed assembly .


Comments are closed here.