Molycorp: What Happened to the U.S. Rare Earth Company?
Molycorp was once one of the biggest names in the push to rebuild the U.S. rare earth industry.
The company owned the Mountain Pass rare earth mine in California and made a large investment to upgrade the mining and processing operation. For a while investors were wildly optimistic. Rare earth prices were high, fears about dependence on China were growing and Mountain Pass was one of the most famous rare earth deposits in the United States.
It did not go as planned.
Costs increased, operations struggled to ramp up and the rare earth market changed. Molycorp filed for bankruptcy under Chapter 11 in 2015. The old shares of Molycorp were eventually canceled and the businesses and assets of Molycorp went their separate ways.
What Was Molycorp?
Molycorp was a U.S. rare earth mining and processing company closely tied to the Mountain Pass mine in California.
The story of Mountain Pass goes much further back than the Molycorp that investors learned about in the 2010s.
Around 1950, the Molybdenum Corporation of America purchased claims at Mountain Pass. After that, rare earth production followed. Mountain Pass became a major source of rare earth materials.
Ownership changed hands over the next few decades. Unocal bought the business in 1977 and was later bought by Chevron. Then an investor group purchased Mountain Pass from Chevron in 2008.
Molycorp, Inc. became a public company in 2010.
It was a significant moment in time.
China dominated much of the rare earth industry and rare earth prices were sharply rising, while rare earth supply concerns were growing. Molycorp provided investors with something hard to come by: exposure to a major U.S. rare earth resource that might be an alternative source of supply.
In 2010 the company’s initial public offering was priced at $14 a share. At one point during the rare earth boom, Molycorp shares traded above $70.
Molycorp wasn’t going to just run the old Mountain Pass mine as it had been run before. The company launched Project Phoenix, a broad modernization and expansion effort.
The goal was lofty. Molycorp wanted to turn Mountain Pass into a big, modern, vertically integrated rare earth operation.
But that very ambition was to become part of the problem.
What Happened to Molycorp?
There’s really no one thing that explains Molycorp’s collapse.
The company was undergoing an expensive expansion and at the same time needed new processing infrastructure to operate reliably, while rare earth market conditions were becoming less favorable.
These problems started to build upon each other.
Project Phoenix Became Expensive
Project Phoenix was supposed to change Mountain Pass.
Molycorp plowed a great deal of money into new mining and processing infrastructure, with projected capital expenditures for Mountain Pass eventually reaching roughly $1.4 billion.
It was a huge undertaking.
Large mining projects often require a large initial investment before they generate consistent cash flow. This is particularly dangerous when the economics of the project depend on commodity prices remaining robust.
Molycorp was spending big against a rare earth market that would look very different just a few years later.
Higher construction and development costs also put more pressure on the company. The greater the amount of capital needed to complete the project, the more important it was for Mountain Pass to ramp up successfully.
Mountain Pass Did Not Ramp Up as Expected
Building the new infrastructure was just one part of the challenge. It had to work at a commercial scale too.
As Mountain Pass was ramping up, Molycorp ran into problems. Some of the concentrator, separation facilities and supporting infrastructure did not perform as expected in a timely fashion.
That’s a big deal in rare earth mining.
Mining is not the end product. The ore is not the end product. The material needs to be concentrated, processed and separated before individual rare earth products can be sold to customers.
A technical problem or a delay anywhere in that chain can have implications for the economics of everything around it.
Molycorp controlled a major rare earth resource. It required a processing system that could turn that resource into reliable commercial production at acceptable costs.
That was harder than expected.
Rare Earth Prices Moved Against Molycorp
And the market changed.
Interest in new production outside China had been prompted by a dramatic surge in rare earth prices around the start of the decade. But those prices didn’t hold at their highs.
As prices softened, the economics behind Molycorp’s expansion got tougher.
This was when the company was still trying to work out the cost and operational issues around Mountain Pass.
By 2015, Molycorp reported that product prices were soft, demand was weak or inconsistent for some products and that ramping up Mountain Pass was delayed. The company was making substantial operating losses and had not yet achieved consolidated operating cash-flow break-even excluding interest.
It was tough to survive the combination.
Molycorp had invested heavily in an operation that was not scaling up as smoothly as hoped, and commodity prices that could have supported those investments were falling.
Molycorp filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection on June 25, 2015.
The lesson is not merely that rare earth prices declined.
Rare earths continued to be strategically important. Mountain Pass continued to be a significant ore body. But strategic importance didn’t automatically make Molycorp’s business economically successful.
RareMetalBlog Analysis: Why Strategic Importance Wasn’t Enough
Molycorp is a useful case study because several parts of the original investment argument were not necessarily wrong.
Mountain Pass really was a significant U.S. rare earth resource. Dependence on China’s rare earth industry really was a strategic concern. And building alternative processing capacity really was important.
None of that guaranteed that Molycorp could turn those advantages into a profitable business.
| Factor | What Looked Attractive | What Went Wrong |
|---|---|---|
| Mountain Pass | Major U.S. rare earth resource | Resource quality did not guarantee profitable processing |
| Rare earth prices | Strong prices supported the expansion case | Prices weakened |
| Project Phoenix | Modern integrated production | Costs rose and the ramp-up was difficult |
| U.S. supply security | Strong strategic rationale | Strategic value did not automatically create positive cash flow |
| Growth | Large production ambitions | Capital requirements arrived before stable economics |
| Molycorp stock | Rare earth boom attracted investors | Common shares were ultimately canceled in bankruptcy |
Source: RareMetalBlog analysis based on Molycorp SEC filings covering Project Phoenix, Mountain Pass operations and the company’s Chapter 11 restructuring.
The distinction between strategic importance and investment economics is the important part.
Rare earths could be important to U.S. manufacturing and national supply security. Mountain Pass could be one of the country’s most significant rare earth resources. China could dominate large parts of global processing.
All three things could be true while Molycorp shareholders still lost their investment.
The reason becomes clearer when the business is viewed as a chain rather than just a mine. A company has to extract the ore, concentrate it, process it, separate the individual products and do all of that at costs that work under real market conditions.
Molycorp was trying to build much of that capability while spending heavily and dealing with a changing commodity market. Strategic demand couldn’t compensate indefinitely for operating losses and capital requirements.
This lesson applies well beyond Molycorp. Across the broader critical minerals sector, a strategically important resource and a successful investment are two different things.
That is also why the economics of processing deserve as much attention as the size of a mineral resource. A deposit can be valuable and strategically important without the company developing it becoming a successful investment.
What Happened to Molycorp After Bankruptcy?
Today, some confusion still exists from Molycorp’s bankruptcy.
Specifically, there are two names that are associated with what happened next: Neo Performance Materials and MP Materials.
They are different chapters in the Molycorp story.
Neo Performance Materials
Molycorp emerged from its Chapter 11 restructuring in August 2016.
The reorganized downstream business was called Neo Performance Materials. Its businesses included rare earth chemicals and oxides, magnetic powders and specialty rare metals.
Former Molycorp common shareholders did not receive shares in the new business. According to Molycorp’s August 2016 SEC filing, the old equity interests were canceled and were not entitled to receive distributions under the reorganization plan.
This is important for anyone looking for Molycorp stock today.
There is no current Molycorp share price. The old public shares no longer exist.
Neo Performance Materials is related to Molycorp via the reorganized downstream business, but that doesn’t mean all of Molycorp’s assets became Neo.
Mountain Pass took a different path.
Mountain Pass and MP Materials
The Mountain Pass mine was separated from the reorganized downstream business during the bankruptcy process.
A new ownership group eventually acquired the Mountain Pass assets from the Molycorp estate in July 2017. Operations were restarted later that year.
Mountain Pass is now operated by MP Materials, but MP Materials is not simply Molycorp under a new name.
That’s an important distinction.
Neo Performance Materials emerged from the restructured downstream operations of Molycorp. MP Materials became the operator of the Mountain Pass mine formerly associated with Molycorp.
So if someone asks what Molycorp is called today, there is no one completely accurate replacement name.
The old company was broken up and its assets went separate ways.
Mountain Pass itself survived. The original investment in Molycorp didn’t.
Molycorp Frequently Asked Questions
Is There Still Molycorp Stock?
No. The old Molycorp common shares were canceled in the company’s bankruptcy restructuring.
That means there isn’t a current Molycorp stock price and the old shares don’t trade today.
MP Materials is publicly traded, but MP Materials stock is not the same as the old Molycorp shares. MP Materials is a separate company that now operates Mountain Pass.
Who Owns the Mountain Pass Mine Today?
Mountain Pass is now operated by MP Materials.
The Mountain Pass assets changed hands after Molycorp’s bankruptcy. MP Materials’ SEC filing states that the company acquired Mountain Pass from the Molycorp estate in July 2017 and restarted operations later that year.
Thus, the Mountain Pass asset survived Molycorp in its old corporate form.
Is Molybdenum a Rare Earth Element?
No. Molybdenum is not a rare earth element.
The confusion is understandable because Molycorp’s history traces back to the Molybdenum Corporation of America. But molybdenum is a different metallic element and is not in the group that is commonly classified as rare earth elements.

Comments are closed here.